Murdoch Mysteries season 1 episode 9 Recap and FAQ
Episode Summary
Detective Murdoch investigates the murder of Roderick Grimesby, initially thought to be a drunkard's natural death. Suspicion falls on Stanley Paulk, who confronts Grimesby over an affair with his wife, and Harcourt Grimesby, Roderick's odd son. Harcourt, communicating through a ventriloquist puppet, Mycroft, confesses but inconsistencies arise. Famous author Arthur Conan Doyle assists Murdoch, leading to a discovery of a twin brother, the real Mycroft. Harcourt's twin, living a hard life after being separated at birth, killed their father for revenge, framing Harcourt. The tragic family saga unfolds, revealing the deep psychological scars of both brothers.
Full Episode S01E09 Recap
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the cause of Roderick Grimesby's death?
Grimesby was murdered by having varnish poured down his throat.
Who initially found Roderick Grimesby's body?
Stanley Paulk found the body when he broke into Grimesby's flat seeking revenge for an affair with his wife.
What did Detective Murdoch initially notice about Grimesby's body?
Murdoch noticed swelling and burning in Grimesby's throat and a strong smell of varnish.
Why did Stanley Paulk confront Grimesby?
Paulk confronted Grimesby for having an affair with his wife.
Was Stanley Paulk right or left-handed?
Stanley Paulk was left-handed.
Who is Harcourt Grimesby?
Harcourt Grimesby is Roderick Grimesby's son, known for being odd and regularly visiting his father.
What unusual trait did Harcourt exhibit during interrogation?
Harcourt communicated through a ventriloquist puppet named Mycroft.
Who is Arthur Conan Doyle in the context of the story?
Arthur Conan Doyle is a famous author who visits to observe Detective Murdoch for character inspiration.
How did Murdoch determine Harcourt was not the murderer?
Murdoch noticed inconsistencies in Harcourt's confession and the physical evidence, suggesting a third party was involved.
Who was actually responsible for Grimesby's murder?
Grimesby's murder was committed by Harcourt's twin brother, Mycroft, who was living as Harcourt.
What was the relationship between Harcourt and Mycroft?
Harcourt and Mycroft were twin brothers, separated at birth, with Mycroft living a hard life on the streets.
Why did Mycroft kill his father?
Mycroft sought revenge against his father for abandoning him and living a life of hardship.
How did Detective Murdoch uncover the truth about the twins?
Murdoch discovered two birth certificates and deduced the existence of a twin from Mycroft's hints and inconsistencies.
What was Arthur Conan Doyle's role in solving the case?
Doyle provided observational insights and assisted Murdoch in understanding the psychological aspects of the case.
What happened to the real Harcourt Grimesby?
The real Harcourt Grimesby was found dead, hidden for years, indicating Mycroft had been impersonating him.
