Murdoch Mysteries season 10 episode 4 Recap and FAQ
Episode Summary
Mr. Shanley, wrongly imprisoned for poisoning his friend, is released due to doubts about the original evidence. Despite being sidelined, Detective Murdoch remains involved, exploring inconsistencies in witnesses' testimonies. Samuel Ramsay, the new husband of Shanley's ex-wife, is mysteriously murdered, with Shanley as a prime suspect. However, further investigation reveals a shocking twist: Shanley's son, Philip, accidentally killed Ramsay while trying to protect his father, leading to a tragic and complex resolution.
Full Episode S10E04 Recap
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Mr. Shanley?
Mr. Shanley was a man wrongly convicted of murdering his friend by poisoning cocoa with thallium.
Why was Shanley released from prison?
Shanley was released because a new test from a lab in New York suggested the original thallium testing might have been incorrect.
Who took over the investigation after Shanley's release?
Detective Watts from Station House One took over the investigation.
What was Detective Murdoch's role after being sidelined?
Murdoch, though sidelined due to concerns of bias, continued to unofficially investigate the case.
Who was Geraldine Hanover?
Geraldine Hanover was a key witness in Shanley's original trial, whose testimony later seemed unreliable.
Who was Samuel Ramsay?
Samuel Ramsay was the new husband of Shanley's ex-wife, found murdered.
Why was Shanley suspected in Ramsay's murder?
Shanley was suspected because he was present at the Ramsay's house the night before the murder.
What happened to the original cocoa tin from Shanley's old case?
The cocoa tin, a key piece of evidence, went missing, complicating the case.
Who was ultimately suspected in Ramsay's murder?
Detective Watts and Murdoch suspected Mrs. Ramsay, Shanley's ex-wife, of the murder.
What was the conclusion of the investigation?
The investigation concluded that Shanley's son, Philip, accidentally killed Ramsay while trying to protect his father.