In an effort to secure a campaign manager for Julian Cantrell's mayoral run, the Cantrell family entertains Mr. Tabbitt, navigating a minefield of his allergies and preferences. Despite their attempts to present a wholesome family image, the evening spirals into chaos with bizarre occurrences, including Valeria's inexplicable glow and miraculous events. The aftermath sees Valeria seeking to shed her unwanted sainthood through deliberate sinning, under the guidance of Ruby Whipple. Ultimately, she learns that her actions, motivated by pride and love for her family, don't qualify as true sinning. As Valeria's saintly glow vanishes, unexpectedly passing to Ruby, the Cantrells grapple with the return to their new normal, minus the divine interventions.